MoArknews.com

Arkansas News / / COURTROOM RULINGS

BEYOND THE BENCH: Former Monroe County District Judge Sentenced to Two Years for Lying to the FBI

By Dave and Dawn Campbell

HELENA-WEST HELENA, Ark. — Thomas David Carruth, a former Monroe County District Court Judge, prosecutor, and defense attorney, has been sentenced to two years in federal prison. The sentence concludes a high-profile public corruption and bribery probe ultimately resulting in a split verdict at trial.

Chief U.S. District Judge D.P. Marshall Jr. handed down the 24-month prison term following a federal trial where a jury convicted Carruth strictly on one count of making false statements to law enforcement. Despite the severe nature of the original indictment, the jury completely acquitted Carruth of all core bribery, honest services wire fraud, and Travel Act violations.

The Secret Recording and Federal Inquiry

According to federal court records, the case stemmed from an April 2022 encounter at Carruth's office. A woman—acting as the girlfriend of a criminal defendant with a pending case in Carruth's Monroe County court—met with the judge to seek help getting her boyfriend's charges dismissed. Unbeknownst to Carruth, the woman secretly recorded the entire interaction.

During the recorded conversation, Carruth made sexually suggestive overtures, explicitly asking the woman about her thoughts on sex and soliciting a "lingerie show." Armed with the audio recording, the FBI launched an investigation and interviewed the judge.

The felony conviction arose entirely from what Carruth told investigators during that interview. He falsely stated to FBI agents he did not request, ask, offer, make overtures about, insinuate, or even think about having sex with the woman. The recorded evidence directly contradicted his denials.

Grand Jury Indictment and Resignation

A federal grand jury originally indicted Carruth on Jan. 3, 2023, on charges of bribery and obstruction of justice. Local reports indicate Carruth had previously resigned his judicial post in August 2022 following a June 2022 federal raid on his home. The full indictment detailed charges related to alleged illicit actions with the defendant's girlfriend.

Yet, during a two-day trial in federal court, prosecutors failed to secure a conviction on the underlying corruption metrics. The jury determined, while the evidence didn't legally satisfy the narrow thresholds required for a federal bribery conviction, Carruth indisputably committed a felony by lying directly to the FBI.

Mandate of Systemic Accountability

Following the sentencing hearing, federal prosecutors emphasized the prison sentence reinforces systemic accountability. United States Attorney Jonathan D. Ross noted the sentence underscores, no one—including a judge—is above the law when interfering with a federal investigation.

Carruth filed an appeal regarding the sufficiency of the evidence. The Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals officially rejected his challenge, cementing his two-year prison sentence.